Tuesday, 27 April 2010

飛女正傳......comedy... stereotype... balance?

Fly With Me (飛女正傳) is a Hong Kong local comedy drama. Many light-hearted plots consistently and deliberately designed to amuse and provoke audience’s laughter by exaggeration the situation, action and outlook etc. comedy drama always puts much more focus on individual character. In Fly With Me, 梁巧芝 (蔡少芬) is the main female character. She is a 35-aged working woman. She can not classify as pretty, her appearance is okay but she has an extraordinarily large rump. Besides, she can convert herself from a normal people to be a superwoman, Janet Bin. Having exaggerating outlook and plots truly fit the element of comedy drama. It can entertain and provoke enjoyment of audience easily.

Even though Fly With Me is a comedy drama, it also state out some Hong Kong’s situation nowadays. 梁巧芝 is a vice-manager of a big bank. She is independent, has great self confident, high education level. She thinks herself as a strongman. She does not have boyfriend, plus her criteria for choosing her partner is very high, she hopes her partner in the future can fit or match every aspect of her. However, she is a choosy, acrimonious and aloof, which similar to the港女 very much. It is a common phenomenon in Hong Kong nowadays. Many girls in Hong Kong just like梁巧芝, they get a high social status, but they are hard to find a partner as well. In this drama, it surely establishes the identity and ideology of local female currently; therefore, Fly With Me definitely gets local audience’s favor and taste.

Though this drama fits local audience very much, this also has stereotypes in it. There are many young, pretty and good body shape woman in the same company with 梁巧芝, they get more advantages compared with her. One the juvenile female which is junior than 梁巧芝, but she gets an excellent body figure, she can promote faster than 梁巧芝. 梁巧芝wants to have plastic surgery with enlarging her breast in order to increase her attractiveness. It enforced represent a society that appearance is more important than person’s strength. It get a stereotype that the ugly female will not success in the real world. It maintains a sharp boundary that if you have a good looking appearance then you will have more accomplishment. It surely enforce the culture of ideal body image of women, ‘slim is good!’, ‘you should have an excellent body shape!’ in the society.

Media, especially television, that everybody often reach it. It usually convey the hegemonic ideology to the public, it is a social construction of ‘reality’. I hope the media can get a balance on the element of comedy and the social ideologies, as it influences the society enormously.


Fung Cho Yi DONNA 10350150

Eason- Time Flies


I am writing a review on Eason Chan’s new mini album called “Time Flies”, which was released on 12th March, 2010. Before commenting on his album, I would like to talk about the singer, Eason himself first. I believe most of us are already quite familiar with Eason. He has been a singer for quite a long period of time and he has married already. He is famous not because of his appearance, but his voice and songs. There is a scandal about Eason recently, that he was in affair with Kay Tse, who is also married.

There are 6 tracks in Eason’s latest released album. The song, “無人之境” is talking about an episode of a person having affair with others. It expresses the feeling of having affairs with others. Though he knows it is wrong to be in relation with someone else, he just could not stop himself from doing so. Some people are guessing that this song might reflect what Eason thought about his relations with Kay Tse.

The song, “大人” is a song talking about the reality of becoming an adult. As we are becoming an adult, we have to take on more responsibility and we are forced to face the reality. We might become more realistic and forget the innocence that we have during our childhood. In this song, Eason may want to remind us not to forget the innocence we used to have even when we have grown up.

Similar to “大人”, “陀飛輪” also talks about the change after being an adult. Personally, this is my favourite song in the album, not only because of the melody, but also the lyrics. I found the lyrics are very meaningful. In Hong Kong, money seems to be everything. People work around the clock in a bid to earn as much as they can. Yet, they have missed or overlooked many other things, which are priceless. Moreover, materialism is often over emphasized in the society of Hong Kong. Therefore, people in Hong Kong often feel empty. Perhaps the lyrics are also the reflection of Eason himself as well. He is a top singer in Hong Kong. He works hard and earns a lot by producing CDs and concert in a year, thus he can afford many luxuries. To him, perhaps being a singer was his dream since he likes singing. However, when he reaches the top of this career, he found that rather than enjoying singing, what makes him continue to be a singer might be money or the status brought by this career.

As most people will listen the melody rather than lyrics, "陀飛輪" uses a “K-song” melody to catch people’s attentions first. When people listen it for few more times, they will start to rethink about what the lyrics are about and I think this is a wise approach for promoting the idea of the song.

In my opinion, this song really suits him and I do not think there are other singers can sing as well as him in this song. He can bring out the mood of this song and touch on people’s emotion. This might explain the reason why this song has become very popular recently.

All and all, I think that this album is quite good as the songs match the image of Eason, that he is a middle aged man who are already married and have reached the top of his career. When many people are admiring what he got, these people may neglect what is the true happiness. After listening Eason’s album, we may really need to think twice on what happiness should be.

Leung Sze Lung, Margaux (10347229)

On Wings of Song - On Wings of Time (Ivana Wong)

Hong Kong is city which incarnated utilitarianism in many aspects of culture in the society, no matter in sense of political or show business. Hong Kong’s idols’ images are usually not very unique, regardless male or female idols, they are typically presented with an attractive appearance, which is normally one of the most effective ways to draw people’s attention. Ivana Wong is different, with no pretty face, she marks an unique image among the contemporary show business culture in Hong Kong.
Ivana’s new album, On Wings of Time, has consistently demonstrated her identical music style which was presented all along her career. Unlike the popular style of music in Hong Kong, Ivana has her own unique music style and does not follow merely the traditional formula of love and romance songs. Love songs are very common in Hong Kong, as we could find most of the popular songs are about love, and more significantly, the songs that people sang the most in karaoke are love songs.
However, Ivana is different, she creates songs that are not all about love, the content could be about friendship, the hardship for being an artist, and etc. In terms of her music style, as mentioned, is unique, songs in the disc like “She threw a match away”, which is a song that sings like old songs from Shanghai, a great different to her usual singing style, and is hard to tell it is Ivana for the first time listening. Another two notable song “About the moon” and “I won’t weep” shares similar style with “She threw a match away”, the three songs are different in melody and lyrics, but is distinguishable that the three songs are made in similar style in melodic aspect intentionally.
Other songs like “Says the moon”, “Big Ben” and “I’m Sorry” are relatively commercial songs when comparing to the remaining songs in the album, talking about love affair, only a bit special when it comes with the lyrics, one like poem and one mentioned not only love but also some attitude towards respectively.
The most remarkable in my opinion is “Mary had a little clock”, the song shares the similar melody with “Big Ben”, but with another set of lyric. In terms of melody, the song had a similar melody with “Big Ben” but with a little different arrangement, the arrangement had made a noticeable change in the atmosphere of the songs, while working along the lyric, the impression of the song is more sad and lonely than “Big Ben”. The lyric is about a tragic story and to challenge the fate through the story.
All songs are written by Ivana herself, and most lyrics are by her too. This is quite different with most of the popular singers in Hong Kong. Though these different are obvious, they could be constructed to satisfy certain people who do not accept the contemporary popular idol market in Hong Kong, which is not minority or less. With there is a market that people will support non-commercial singers, companies will not neglect the chance to make money from those targets. And this is why singer-song writers are becoming more common in Hong Kong’s show business, but even with images to package, the songs should remain with certain quality or massive advertisement before a singer could be popular inside this circle, it is therefore Ivana Wong could still stand around firmly in Hong Kong.

Chan Chung Wai, Joe

Echoes of the Rainbow 歲月神偷, collective memory?

The film which I want to talk about is “Echoes of the Rainbow 歲月神偷”, which is directed by Alex Law with the stars Simon Yam 任達華 and Sandra Ng 吳君如. “Echoes of the Rainbow” is focusing on a family with four members. Yam acts father, Ng acts mother, Lee Chi Ting acts Desmond who is elder brother and Chung Siu To acts younger brother. They are living in Wing Lee Street with their shoes shop. Desmond is an excellent student in Diocesan Boys' School and fall in love with a girl called Flora. Younger brother is a naughty boy, his father always angry with the bad academic results of younger brother. Unfortunately, Desmond got blood cancer and died in the film. Then younger brother is enlighten because of brother’s death and became an excellent student in Diocesan Boys’ School also.

Actually the story of this film is very simple. A hard family oppressed by corruption, earn money hardly to rise up their son, elder son is great but having an unfortunate fate, and so the younger son is enlighten and become great too. For the story, there is nothing for audience to self-examine, but I believe 60s people can taste their life again through the film. The director has putted much effort in describing the time of 60s. Such as the trend of “fighting fish”, habit of breeding fish, hair cutting shop, school on the roof, shop opened by Shang Hai people, also the “famous” Wing Lee Street.

Why I quote “famous” to describe Wing Lee Street? May be we can talk about the sub-idea of “Echoes of the Rainbow” first. Wing Lee Street is a scene of this film, which is a street preserving many old style stuffs. And the director of this film also claimed to preserve this street in order to protect Hong Kong people’s collective memory.

I have heard the terms “collective memory” during the lecture, and I have found some definitions of “collective memory” from Wiki. “The collective memory is shared, passed on and also constructed by the group, or modern society.” Okay, I can see the words “shared”, “constructed by the group, or modern society”. I believe Star Ferry Pier is a collective memory, because it can be a symbol of Hong Kong, a pier which connects Hong Kong Island and Kowloon before MTR existed, but how about Wing Lee Street? I have found some information of Wing Lee Street, and discovered this street is a place for children who are living in there to play, also with some old buildings and items. And the main point is, how can this street be a collective memory? I can’t see any element of sharing, at least I don’t have. The reason why people support not to redevelop this street is mainly because of watched this film? I believe some traditional things are needed to be preserved, but I also believe something needs to be modified or reconstructed in order to catch up the development.

May be I am not living in Wing Lee Street or simply I'm rude, I still unable to see this street as a collective memory. which the terms “collective memory” has abused.

Back to the film, my comment to this film is detail description of old era but very simple story. Whole story is unable to match up with the title “Time, the thief”. Elder brother is killed by caner, but not time. Typhoon destroyed the home of characters, but it is an accident. The first image of thing which can be stolen by time is usually age. Director wants every character have lost something in the story, such as mother lost her elder son and husband, flora lost her lover, younger brother lost his brohter and father, Desmond lost his life. However, all the things which they lost are not caused by time, that’s why I say the story is not matching up with the film title, may be it has matched in 60s people's and the director's view.

Also, there is one funny point in this film. Is it so difficult to find another guy rather than the one acting Desmond to act the younger son in secondary school period? In the cinema, most audience laughed for the last funny scene which the younger brother in secondary school period comes out with exactly his brother’s face, only the hair style is changed, what a joke……


Kwan Yat Hin, Yoshi 10421538

Film review of “Alice in wonderland” –Tim Burton

“Alice in wonderland” is a latest 3-D film on show which is directed by Tim Burton whom specializes in dark and aberrant-themed film. The genre of this film can be seen as a blend of live action and animation, the traditional fairy tale was overthrown to be a dark adult fairy with fully black humor factors which is a typical vision of Burton. This strong personal style of Burdon was clearly revealed at the setting and character part of scene. To instance, while Burden tended to use some dark elements and “death” in his story telling, the color used in most of the props and scenes are neither dull color nor black and white. These settings helped to create a baroque style world view of this story. Meanwhile the designs of the characters are also stereotypical Burdon’s style which is full of grotesque characteristic. For example, the white hair and strange active of White Queen; Peculiar figure of Red Queen with her Astonishing big head and bombastic eye mask; Whimsical Mad Hatter with his strange hair style. All of these are the typical personal stamps of Burton’s signature. What’s more, regarding to the biography of Burdon, his film style was greatly constructed by his personal experience in his childhood. The protagonists in his work were mostly marginalized, hard to communicate with others and a bit strange of their appearances or behaviors. To instance, the eccentric owner of chocolate factory Willy Wonka in his film “Charlie and the Chocolate Factory” or the bloody barber in “The Demon Barber of Fleet Street” are both of the typical examples of Burton’s creation. Likewise, Alice, the protagonist in the latest film is also representing these kinds of characteristic in which she often considers herself as an outsider while she often feel incompatible with the common norm and sense that everybody believe in. She thinks it is difficult for her to fit in the adult world with her distinctive way of thinking and so she evades making any decisions about her life.


Many people think that Tim Burton’s “single organizing intelligence” is missing in this film because of the corporation with Disneyland had restrain him under a family film formula which is hard for him to express his distinctive world view and photography. Regarding to this argument, I do have a different point of view. As the central theme of Burton’s work are mainly narratives of how a outsider being isolated and seeking for something , whatever their identities , their dreams or an answer for their lives, through this process they are being adopt or influencing people and the society surrounding them. This core value of Burton’s work is still kept in the film, while Alice is also searching how her life should be and her real identity in the film. Somehow it had been revealed in the film that she keeps being asked by others with the question “who is Alice?” and being told with an answer like “Alice should be…”These kinds of speech are ceaselessly appearing throughout the whole film. Therefore, it is failed to say that Burden had lost his own style in this new production but much fair to see him just changed the way to express his individual style .It is hoped to be understandable by his new audiences: families including both adults and children who are not common audiences of Burton’s films.

Ng Wing Yan , Connie
Student Num:10423649

Echoes of The Rainbow (歲月神偷)




Echoes of The Rainbow (歲月神偷) is a 2009 Hong Kong film directed by Alex Law, Law Kai Yui and his wife and starring Simon Yam and Sandra Ng. This film won the Crystal Bear for the Best Film at the 2010 Berlin Film Festival. The background of the film is 60s Hong Kong and the story is about incident in one Hong Kong local family. Content of the story is based on some of Alex Law’s childhood and his experience. This film is full of Hong Kong 60s feelings and colors, also it contains and represents many collective memories and local experiences among Hong Kong people, so Hong Kong people have sympathetic responses when they are watching the film. It is not difficult to find that there are many scenes in the film, which show those difficult days in the 60s Hong Kong and are very familiar with the living in last generation. For instance, one police who receives blatantly bribes, nurses got extra fee from patients’ family before working. Almost all the Hong Kong people had lived in that period of time, had experienced these kinds of scenes, such as our parents and grandparents, and they will have strong feelings after watching this film. Moreover, we can also see a lot of characters with British elements in the film as it was a period that Hong Kong was colonized by British, for example, there are some dialogues contain Cantonese and English together, such as Sandra Ng always says “Good fit” with Cantonese dialogues in the film.

At that period of 60s, Hong Kong was standing on an anarchy condition. Hong Kong was still governed by British and had to face and endure the suppression of government, moreover, they had to face the impact about movement in mainland China at the same time. The film can show that kind of anarchy condition clearly. On the other hand, we can see the Hong Kong core values through the film. It emphasizes family value in the film and the story line is set around one family and their experiences. Family value is one very important thing and has been concerned a lot by Hong Kong people, so there are many scenes about dinner time and the family having dinner with neighbors outside the house. We can see that they live in good neighborhood with one another and it fits the spirit of “neighborhood watch” in Hong Kong 60s period, neighbors would love to help each other.

Alex law and his wife have been directing movie together and the theme of their films are mainly about family or love and background generally set in Hong Kong. This film is totally matching the style of what he likes, we can see the different types of love in the film, such as love between neighborhood, brotherhood, first love, sons and parents and husband and wife. The loves in the film are very exquisite and we seem to be able to travel back to 60s Hong Kong through this film. I think this is one reason of why this film could touch Hong Kong people’s heart and got a great success.
Asian Studies
Hong Yi Kwan, Cheyenne (10423651)

Mr. Like Black


On 6th Feb 2010, Mr.’s latest album Like Black was released and it attracts lots of their fans to purchase.

This album is very similar to the previous one If I Am… which is released in last September. In the album Like Black, there are 8 songs which are the remix version with only 2 new songs. Some may think this album is not really worthy to pay for; however, in the cultural industry production system, it is the cheapest way to earn the biggest money by reproducing the original or existing product. “The lowest cost, the largest reciprocate” is the most ideal approach for the capitalists. When their music becomes popular, the marketing strategy has changed to how to maintain the selling of the CD albums. Therefore they choose to release this album in 5 months after the previous album was released. But due to the time limit to produce new songs, the better way to sell the album is remix or modify the existing ones. As a result the remixed version in the album Like Black occupied the most of the songs.

Since the capital to produce new songs has been reserved, so that there can be lots of promotions and advertisements from different media such as radio, magazines to help the company to sell the album. Besides, this album is a cooperation with famous artist Eric Kot (葛民輝) to promote together. Therefore the name of the CD album “Like Black” is also as same as this local brand name established by Eric Kot. And this crossover shows that the album is an inter-textual cultural product. Since there is a strong financial and cultural background of this album, so the album was hot in naturally.

Rock music, which is what this music group would like to promote, is an underground music originally, but nowadays it goes to the mainstream popular music. Through purchasing Mr.’s album, the fans can establish their identity as rock devotees. It is because identity could be established by what things you buy, and in the process of purchasing, it reveals that you are enthusiastic and appreciate in rock and roll. And this phenomenon is revived since the fading away among Hong Kong youngsters of the famous local band Beyond.

The reason that Mr. is attractive among Hong Kong youngsters is because the local music industry is lack of the element of rock music. Therefore when music of Mr. being accepted in the mainstream, there is a whirlwind of rock fans emerged again after the fade away of Beyond. And Beyond’s fading out causes the disappearance of band sound and rock music in Hong Kong music industry. And that is why even though there are some news criticize them are plagiarizing other songs, there are still lots of hardcore fans supporting their music. Their motivation is caused by the thirst of band sound.

by George Chung 10350090