Wednesday 16 April 2014

Online Review - Triumph in the Skies II (衝上雲霄2)


Story Outline:

TV dramas in Hong Kong always create ideology to the audience. In the past, they always follow the Confucian and feudal ways of thinking emphasizing ‘men are stronger than women’ and some standard couple relationship. They created many icons and narratives from which cultural identities can be constructed. Heroes in many TV dramas took the leading role in workplace, they were always with male chauvinism, and heroines were always with soft character. Nowadays, media amplified that those feudal thoughts are outdated, and new ideology was spread through the TV dramas. Although Triumph in the Skies II was not the first TV drama to reflect that, it was the best reflector in these years.

Before, TV dramas stereotyped the characteristics of men and women, and they always contained rational men and emotional women. Some jobs were also set to be male-dominant (e.g. professionals like pilot and engineer) or female-dominant (e.g. airhostess). But in Triumph in the Skies II, Fergus was a male airline steward, Holiday and Win were female pilot and Summer was a female engineer. Although their bosses were the opposite sex, it showed the rising status of women and sexual equality in reality nowadays.


Fergus (right) - A male airline steward

Summer - A female engineer

Holiday (middle) - A female pilot

In the text, the heroine (Holiday) was shaped to be outwardly soft and inwardly hard; the hero (Samuel) was outwardly hard and inwardly soft. It broke the regular rule of character setting which always emphasized men were stronger than women. Samuel was a solemn man, he took everything serious. After his wife (Zoe) died, he blamed himself and escaped the reality since he could not accompany Zoe till her death. Holiday was a girl who always acted impetuously. Her boyfriend (Daniel) disappeared after an aviation accident. Although she was upset and did not believe Daniel was dead, she tried to acquaint herself with Daniel’s thought. At the end, Holiday found that Daniel really loved her and planned to propose to her before he died, she let it go and started her new life, and she even helped Samuel to release his pressure and told him not to stick with the sadness of Zoe’s death. It reversed the traditional male and female character setting.

As for the couple relationship, the text constructed some identities. Although Hong Kong people are more open-minded nowadays, the older generation still considers Hong Kong as a patriarchal society. Base on the feudal thoughts, they think that in an ideal relationship, male should profess first; female should be younger and should not be divorced or pregnant before. People who break these rules are stigmatised by the older generation. But in the text, it broke the stereotyped representation: Josie professed to Issac; Heather, who had divorced, was older than Roy; Coco was a surrogate mother but Jim Jim still accepted and asked her to be his girlfriend. 

Heather and Roy

Coco and Jim Jim

In this text, Jayden and Roy were classified as ‘ideal men’, and Heather was classified as ‘leftover lady’. It drew the boundary and became the rule to identify people, and also affected how the audiences see themselves and others. TV dramas and our cultural identities are interrelated indeed.

(512 words)

Lam Po Yi Bowie
10553759/21236316


No comments:

Post a Comment