Stereotype
of annoying mother of boyfriend/ mother-in-law
‘Come Home
Love’(愛回家) is a drama by TVB. Wan Suk Han (acted by Ma
Hoi Lun) is mother of Leung Yin Fun (acted by Ng Ka Lok), and Ma Yau (acted by
Kwok Siu Wan) is Leung Yin Fun’s girlfriend. In the story, Wan Suk Han works in
the same restaurant with Ma Yau. Before Wan know Ma’s relationship with her
son, Wan and Ma had arguments on restaurant issues. Since then, Wan’s annoying
characters were revealed especially in front of Ma.
First, she
forces her son to choose between Ma and her. In the drama, Wan used to ask
Leung who he will save if Ma and she fall into the sea. On the other hand, she
always compares between Ma and her. For example, Wan was jealous and complained
to her son as he bought a handbag to Ma. These behaviours show her jealousy and
dislike to Ma.
Second, she
always suspects Ma is not a good person and will harm Leung and her. For
example, when Ma tried to show sincerity to Wan by making her coffee, Wan
immediately popped up in mind that Ma was trying to poison her. Also, she
believes Ma is faking so she always tells Leung not to trust Ma.
Third, she treats Ma as a competitor, which she always wants to show she is more capable to run the restaurant at all costs. In one of the episodes, Wan went to Taiwan deliberately for buying a coffee machine as she simply believed that coffee machine could help her to gain trust from employer and beat Ma.
The behaviours mentioned above reflect a negative relationship between mother-in-law distrusts and daughter-in-law. A mother-in-law can try all possible ways to break the relationship between the couple, at the same time to make her son fall into dilemma though.
Relationship
between mother-in-law and daughter-in-law is an important issue in each family
as it may relate to everyone. Therefore, this is an interesting theme for
broadcasting company to produce drama. The typical way to show this distrust
relationship is to create an irrational, highhanded, and annoying mother-in-law
who only believes the daughter-in-law fakes and lies to her son. However, this
representation of ‘mother-in-law’s ’jealousy and annoyance is stereotyping them.
In reality,
not all mother-in-law are like Wan, but as ‘annoying mother-in-law’ can make
the drama more sensational and gain more public attention. TVB is willing to
exaggerating the irrational behaviours and keep stereotyping. For example in
2008, Wars of In-Laws (我的野蠻奶奶) has more emphasis and stereotypes
about mother-in-law, but it still gained very high popularity in Hong Kong
which reflect audiences had sympathy and find the ideas in the drama
interesting. Therefore, stereotyping will still be an element in TV drama in
future.
Leung Wing Lum, Amy (10517445/ 21047996)
An interesting review showing the stereotypical images of “annoying mother of lover” in a situation comedy. Some concrete examples (e.g., specific scenes) have been cited to analyze the cultural representations embodied by the characters.
ReplyDeletePerhaps you could also identify some distinctive features of situation comedy and relate them to your textual/semiotic analysis. Do you think such kind of stereotypical portrayal of middle-aged women/mothers appear more often in the selected TV genre?